This $300 robot can answer science questions and tell jokes. But is it smart enough to hold your interest?
When I tell my daughters, ages 6 and 9, that I have a new robot to show them, they perk up. I then take Professor Einstein out of the box.
“Ahhhh!” they both cry, wide-eyed.
My wife walks into the room: “Ahhh!”
Yep, Professor Einstein doesn’t look like your typical robot.
This very expressive, very wacky robotic character is a creation of Hanson Robotics, which calls it “your personal genius.” Professor Einstein can chat about science, tell jokes, check on the weather, and, naturally, quote Einstein himself. It connects to a companion app with games, videos, and interactive lessons.
And it’s constantly sticking out its tongue.
Professor Einstein is now available on eBay for a promotional price of US $250 (you also get a $50 eBay gift card). Early next month, Hanson Robotics will sell it on its website, as well as on Amazon and other retailers, for $300.
Personally, I’ve met other lifelike robots and don’t find them creepy at all. I think Professor Einstein looks pretty cool.
I put the robot on a desk and start searching for the power switch. My daughters look on and eventually warm up to it. They start poking its nose, cheeks, mustache, eyeballs. I try to get the unruly hair off its face. “I can probably do a half ponytail on him,” Paloma offers.
Gabi finds the power switch. It’s tucked under the robot’s shirt, on its back. “It’s on its butt!” she laughs. “That’s his back,” I say. “Butt,” she insists.
We flip the butt-switch and Professor Einstein comes alive. The initial setup involves a bunch of steps. The robot guides us through the process. It has only limited capability when offline, so it asks to connect to the Wi-Fi and to an iPad app, which we download from the App Store.
A handy booklet lists some of the things you can ask the robot. My daughters ask Professor Einstein to stick out its tongue, point its finger, take a walk, and “go crazy.” This last command results in a series of crazy expressions. They laugh.
But other times Professor Einstein seems confused by our questions. When I ask, “How much is 2 plus 2?” it pauses and says, “Sorry, I could not find an answer to that question.” Hmm. I ask again, and this time the robot answers with names of actors from a movie—we can’t quite figure out. I then ask, “What is the meaning of life?” A nonsensical answer again.
That’s a problem for any talking robot. Today, people, even kids, are used to capable voice-based agents like Siri, Alexa, and Google Home. When you interact with a system that offers an inferior experience, you get disappointed very fast. That’s especially true for a robot that calls itself a genius.
We go back to the suggested questions in the booklet, like “What is the general theory of relativity?”
We also ask, “Who is Albert Einstein?”
And of course, “Professor Einstein, stick out your tongue!”
This is the first consumer robot from Hanson Robotics, which is based in Hong Kong. The company was founded by Dr. David Hanson, a roboticist known for creating incredibly realistic androids. One of them is Sophia, which Dr. Hanson recently demonstrated on the Tonight Show. Another is Alberto Hubo, a humanoid with an Einstein head, which seems like a predecessor to the newer, smaller Einstein.
Dr. Hanson tells me that his past robot creations showed the value of “deeply engaging interactions between human and robot, including facial expressions, conversation, and nonverbal communication.” He wanted Professor Einstein to have the same qualities.
Andy Rifkin, Hanson Robotics’ CTO and a former Mattel senior executive, argues that a physical robot has advantages over a virtual character. For example, studies showed that in some educational settings “physical embodiment can yield measurable learning gains,” he says.
Over the past three years, Hanson Robotics went through many versions of Professor Einstein. The final design is 37 centimeters (14.5 inches) tall. Here are the tech specs:
- The main compute board uses an ARM7 processor;
- Two NiMH rechargeable batteries hide inside the feet, allowing the robot to run for 3 hours;
- The main audio input is a microphone on its chest; two additional mics on the sides of the head help with sound direction location;
- Also on its chest is a camera, used to track faces and help the robot maintain eye contact;
- Infrared sensors in the bottom of the shoes prevent the robot from walking off of a table;
- For movement, the robot uses nine coreless dc motors with custom gearboxes. Motors on the legs and feet allow it to walk. There are five motors in the face alone, used to create the different facial expressions.
My wife asks about the microphones and cameras. There are growing privacy and security concerns as people bring more Internet-connected devices into the home. Users want to be certain that these gizmos can’t be hacked and used for spying. Rifkin says digital certificates and encryption protect the data transmissions, and no personal images or audio are stored in the cloud.
Will Professor Einstein be a hit? I see two big challenges. The first is the price. At $300, it is not cheap, and buyers, especially parents, will want to make sure the robot doesn’t get tossed aside after 5 minutes of play. Indeed, that’s the second challenge: Is the robot fun enough so kids keep coming back to play with it?
My daughters often enjoy playing with their old robots. They are always discovering new features, trying new things with them. So I think the same could happen with Professor Einstein.
I find the companion app, called Stein-O-Matic, a bit overwhelming. But maybe my daughters will be more adept at exploring all of its modules. That’s one way I can see the robot getting more use over time. In fact, it’s something that seems to be working for other robots, including Cozmo, Sphero, Dash and Dot, and Kamigami.
Hanson Robotics plans to continue upgrading the app and the robot’s software. They’re also working on a new coding app that’ll let users program their own interactions with the robot. That should be fun: You could create your own trivia games, for example, about the topics you like.
In the meantime, I know my daughters have already found their favorite feature: